Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Judge grants lower bail for woman who claims self-defense in 2019 shooting death of Westfield man
alert top story

Judge grants lower bail for woman who claims self-defense in 2019 shooting death of Westfield man

Amber Lundgren homicide hearing (copy)

Amber Lundgren sits quietly crying next to her attorney Andrew Martinez during a preliminary hearing in January at the Sauk County Courthouse. Lundgren faces life imprisonment for a first-degree intentional homicide charge after admittedly shooting a man in September.

A woman who allegedly admitted to killing a man was successful Monday in a petition to reduce a cash bond that has held her in the Sauk County Jail for 11 months.

Amber Lundgren, 36, Richland Center, is charged with first-degree intentional homicide and a misdemeanor of carrying a concealed weapon. Lundgren admitted to shooting 37-year-old Christopher Lytle of Westfield in September 2019 and claimed her actions were self-defense.

Amber M. Lundgren


During the motion hearing Monday to consider a reduction in her bail as requested by Lundgren’s attorney Andrew Martinez, Sauk County Circuit Court Judge Michael Screnock adjusted the bail to $250,000. It was initially set at $500,000 by Circuit Court Judge Patricia Barrett, who approved a request for a new judge Feb. 17 and was replaced by Screnock.

If Lundgren posts bond, she may not have any contact with family members of the victim, cannot leave the state and must surrender a passport, if she has one, to the Sauk County Sheriff’s Office.

According to the criminal complaint, Lundgren told detectives that she met Lytle outside the Wisconsin Dells Ho-Chunk casino in September 2019 after exchanging text messages for a few weeks. She picked up Lytle in her vehicle, which was captured on cameras by the casino security department and reported to local authorities.

Christopher John Lytle


According to the criminal complaint, Lundgren admitted during interviews with detectives in mid-October to shooting Lytle. She said Lytle had touched her inappropriately more than once while she was driving. When she rebuffed his sexual advances and requests to “get high,” Lundgren said Lytle hit her in the face more than once as they reached a turnaround dead-end on North Hein Road near Levee Road in the town of Fairfield.

Woman accused of homicide tells Sauk County investigators she acted in self-defense during sex assault

According to the complaint, Lundgren confessed to shooting Lytle after he exited the vehicle, walked around to her door and pulled her out of the driver’s seat. Lundgren told the detectives that he “tried to force himself on top of her” but she was able to roll away after striking him with her knee. She then reached for the .38-caliber handgun she kept in her purse and claimed that she could see him kneeling in the road with his back turned when she shot at him. Lundgren told detectives she used the vehicle to balance herself as she leaned over, afraid he would “get back up” and shot him in the back of the neck again.

A UW pathologist reported after an examination that Lytle died due to two gunshots to the back of his neck and head area.

Sauk County homicide victim named

Lundgren told the detectives that she threw both gun cartridges in a dumpster in Richland Center the next day. The gun was then stored at her parents’ home where it was later found by authorities.

If convicted, Lundgren faces life in prison. She is scheduled to return to court Oct. 27.

Follow Bridget on Twitter @cookebridget or contact her at 608-745-3513.

Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alert

Breaking News