FROSTMAN COLUMN: Justice Kelly has earned your support

FROSTMAN COLUMN: Justice Kelly has earned your support

  • 0

Another week passes, and more uncertainty pervades every facet of our day-to-day lives as the pandemic continues to impact our nation and our world. Ideally, this day sees you experiencing those small victories or moments of good that will undoubtedly continue in these uncharted waters.

As the spring election approaches, voters are being implored to seek out absentee measures for voting. Please note this column is prepared several days in advance of publication, so there is a possibility procedures may change, and more than ever, it is critically important for voters to be informed on the process. I encourage all to visit for the latest updates, and contact your municipal clerks for information.

This election includes the Democratic presidential primary, and Joe Biden appears to have a lock on the nomination. It will also feature a host of county board and municipal races across the state. The one statewide race this year is for a seat on the Wisconsin Supreme Court. Much like last year’s race between Justice Brian Hagedorn and Lisa Neubauer, this race features a definitive contrast in judicial styles and philosophies.

A non-partisan race, it nonetheless has candidates distinctively supported by the political parties. Incumbent Justice Daniel Kelly was appointed to the high court in 2016 by then-Gov. Scott Walker to replace a retiring Justice David Prosser, and is generally favored by Republicans and conservatives. Dane County Judge Jill Karofsky is typically preferred by Democrats and liberals. It’s become commonplace in the last several Supreme Court races to have these distinct differences in candidates.

The cavalcade of recent events, and limitations on the sizes of gatherings and meetings has impacted our ability to see and hear from these candidates. Several expected forums featuring both candidates have been cancelled, making it more of a challenge for voters to get informed. With COVID-19 rightfully dominating the headlines, whether you go to work, visit the grocery store or other commonplace activities are impacted.

Those limitations don’t mean we don’t have any information from which to discern. On March 16, the Cap Times did an in-depth dive on the contrast between the candidates. Kelly stated “his is a message that’s resonating with voters because they want justices who ‘just apply the law,’” and that “his decisions are based on a chain of ‘rigorous logic’ laid out in his rulings.

The story further reported “elected as a Dane County judge three years ago, Karofsky pledged she would ‘advocate for social justice issues’ in her role,” (telling) the UW Madison Pre-Law Society she supports overhauling the state’s criminal justice system.”

We are in a time of great criticism of law enforcement, including their methods and procedures. What is telling to the general public is whether law enforcement officials feel supported by other aspects of the criminal justice system, including judges.

I would encourage voters to check out the respective websites and review the law enforcement endorsements of the respective candidates. Kelly is at, Karofsky at As of March 22, Justice Kelly had the endorsement of 44 county sheriffs out of 72 Wisconsin counties. Judge Karofsky had five. A nearly ten-to-one overwhelming endorsement of Justice Kelly by those boots on the ground in law enforcement.

Karofsky’s television ads have tried to paint Kelly as an “extremist” who opposes abortion and favors school choice. Kelly’s positions on those topics aren’t really a part of the rationale for a Supreme Court justice, but there are certainly millions of Wisconsinites that would take those stances as far less than “extreme,” to the point of offering their support for Justice Kelly.

It’s also a grave matter of concern when you hear the words “social justice” used by any judge at any level. The role of the Supreme Court of the State of Wisconsin is to simply apply the law as it is currently written. In depictions of the judiciary, the scales of justice are always pictured with a blindfold.

A March 17 Journal Sentinel story, described how all campaigns are changing their tactics and strategies to cope with the ever-evolving landscape around us all. Gone are the campaign rallies, fundraisers, door knocking and meet-and-greets that would be so prevalent in the upcoming weeks. They’ve been replaced by more phone calls, postcards, and social media posts.

This election will likely be different than many for most, but as always, we ask for the effort to make your voice heard. Justice Kelly merits your support for ten more years as a Supreme Court justice, and I hope you will join me in that support. Stay safe, and we will persevere.

Scott Frostman lives in Baraboo and has roots throughout Wisconsin. He believes anyone can make a difference and can be reached at

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

  • Updated

We're in this together. (Just don't stand so close.) We're unified in our goal. (But look, 6 feet away, OK?) If you haven't been outside lately, let me paint a picture: People are outside but not many people are outside, and wherever people are going right now - to grocery stores, jogging trails, gas stations - an elaborate dance is happening, a social distancing pas de deux, being learned on ...

Joe, a semiretired 81-year-old, never expected his Italy guys' trip to thrust him into the front ranks of COVID-19 patients. Joe's story goes against the grain of news about the coronavirus now gripping the world and providing epidemiologists and public health experts with the challenge of their professional lives. Joe is a patient of a medical colleague, and he and his wife gave me permission ...

People around the world are bemoaning having to stay mostly at home for some weeks because of COVID-19. After just a day or two - even with the internet, Netflix, books, music, games, FaceTime and endless other ways to entertain themselves and stay connected, not to mention walks in the park and trips to the grocery store - many people reported feeling lonely, bored, restless, or even ...

You don't notice Joe Biden's stutter when he's speaking most of the time. He didn't stutter during the debate on March 15, for example. But as a stutterer, I recognized the signs of a master stutterer at work. Seeing Biden on stage takes me back to my childhood. I've watched him for years and recognize the familiar tricks. Noticed him struggling with a phrase or name he's uttered a million ...

Most people I know hate Chicago's O'Hare International Airport. For me, that chaotic place at the end of the Kennedy Expressway has always been a source of deep comfort. If anything were to go wrong with my independent, 96-year-old mum in Great Britain, I've told myself since moving to Chicago 30 years ago, I can be at her side tomorrow morning. In fact, being as American Airlines has long ...

  • Updated

I have a confession to make, something that in the age of COVID-19 seems almost seditious: daily, up-close human contact is an indispensable part of my life. I use a motorized wheelchair and I need assistance doing the routine things everyone does every day, like getting dressed and getting out of bed and doing laundry and all that. I've hired a crew of people to come in and help me do that ...

The $2 trillion stimulus package passed by the Senate Wednesday night provides enormous loans to airlines and other businesses as well as rebates of $1,200 to most low- and middle-income U.S. adults. But the legislation bars an important group from receiving rebates: elderly and disabled adults who are financially dependent on family members. The result is that the largest aid package in U.S. ...

"Never let a serious crisis go to waste," Rahm Emanuel advised in the midst of the 2008 financial meltdown. It's advice that China appears to have taken to heart. For as the world grapples with how to control a pandemic that has now spread to 175 nations, infected hundreds of thousands and killed more than 20,000 people, China is asserting itself as the global savior that will lead the world ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alert

Breaking News