EDITORIAL: Don't ignore hidden state budget deficit
EDITORIAL: Don't ignore hidden state budget deficit

EDITORIAL: Don't ignore hidden state budget deficit

  • 0

Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald, R-Juneau, is calling for another tax cut.

Other lawmakers want to spend $10 million on water quality.

Both ideas appear to be popular.

But before state leaders approve more tax breaks or spend money that isn’t in the state budget, they should ask a simple question: Can Wisconsin afford it?

The state Department of Administration quietly posted its Comprehensive Annual Fiscal Report in late December. The document is important because it calculates the state’s finances using generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP).

The report, which is prepared the same way businesses put together financial summaries for shareholders, showed the state had a budget deficit of $773 million at the end of its last fiscal year on June 30, 2019.

This hidden deficit demands attention because it shows the state could be vulnerable if today’s strong economy turns toward recession.

By law, Wisconsin’s budget must be balanced. But state leaders use “cash accounting” to build their spending plan. Cash accounting is like balancing your checkbook without accounting for credit card purchases you didn’t pay off. It’s a narrower view of state finances that doesn’t factor in all future commitments.

Under cash accounting, Fitzgerald and others can claim the state has extra money to play with. But GAAP accounting unmasks budget tricks and future obligations that wipe away the supposed surplus.

Former Gov. Scott Walker pledged to move the state to GAAP accounting. And in 2012, Republicans who run the state Assembly — led by four members who were certified public accountants — approved a joint resolution with bipartisan support that would have required GAAP accounting.

Unfortunately, the bill died in Fitzgerald’s state Senate.

Fast forward to today, and Gov. Tony Evers has said GAAP is “something to work toward.” The Legislature should respond by reviving its push for more transparent and broader accounting rules.

Today’s GAAP deficit of $773 million is actually down from $1.25 billion at the end of the 2018 fiscal year. And a decade ago, the GAAP deficit was $2.7 billion.

That suggests progress.

“Temporarily, it’s really good news,” said Dale Knapp, director of Forward Analytics, the research arm of the Wisconsin Counties Association. “But it is only temporary.”

Knapp said Thursday that higher spending and tax reductions in the latest state budget will send the GAAP deficit back toward $1.25 billion “and probably higher.”

That means the Legislature, as it wraps up its work this spring, should scrutinize calls for tax cuts and new spending that isn’t in the state budget. As the state’s annual report using GAAP accounting shows, the state’s financial position isn’t nearly as solid as it should be.

Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alert

Breaking News